1 Products and services may be offered by Royal Bank of Canada or by a separate corporate entity affiliated with Royal Bank of Canada, including but not limited to Royal Mutual Funds Inc., RBC Direct Investing Inc. (Member–Canadian Investor Protection Fund), RBC InvestEase Inc., RBC Global Asset Management Inc., Royal Trust Company or The Royal Trust Corporation of Canada
For some of us, it’s battling inflation; for others, it’s coming to terms with pandemic-era spending habits. Either way, a lot of us are reviewing what we spend on. But it’s not just about cutting out luxuries; it’s about determining what brings value to your life.
Kumiko Love, accredited financial counselor and author of My Money, My Way, says that setting a budget doesn’t have to leave you feeling deprived. Instead, spending with greater intention can enhance your overall well-being.
When a lot of people think ‘budgeting,’ they think dollars and cents. Is that all there is to it?
This journey of spending less is not about the dollar amounts; it’s about what we’re trying to accomplish with our money and what brings joy to our life. So, it’s about cutting back on the things that don’t bring value versus spending more on things that are truly important.
So, it makes sense to look at budgeting holistically and through a value lens?
Budgeting is about honouring you. You get to say what’s important and where your money should go. That is such a builder of financial confidence!
You can consider budgeting a process of self-discovery. The more you grow to understand about yourself, the better spending decisions you can make. People say to take emotions out of finances, but my financial philosophy is all about using emotions as a motivational tool. When you’re doing “robot work” — meaning, doing things that other people dictate — you can hit all these goals and feel absolutely nothing. My budget has to be based on how I define success for myself.
When evaluating spending, how do you decide what you consider a luxury, a nice-to-have or a must?
The distinction between those things is very personal. One person might say that they “need” a new car because they need to take the kids to daycare and themselves to a job. Another might say that they “need” a new car because they want something nicer-looking.
I think it’s sometimes easier to identify a need when it’s not being met. If your life would spin into chaos without it, then it’s a need. You have to think about each item in terms of the consequences of not having it.
How do those categories help people to feel empowered instead of deprived?
Empowerment comes with realizing what we’re truly fighting for. People might say, well, I’m empowered when I save this much money, or when I pay off this much debt, or put this amount in their retirement account. But what they’re really saying is, I feel empowered in preparing for a future I desire. Not having to stay at a job. Not having to stay in an abusive relationship. Being able to pursue a passion project. It’s about a way of living.
Do you have any tips for putting those decisions to work and the actual act of cutting back spending?
I call this exercise “the flow” and here’s how it works:
First, what are my fixed expenses? I make a list of the monthly things I have to pay, like car insurance, rent and daycare.
Second, I take my income minus those fixed expenses, and that’s the money for variable expenses. They’re the hardest to predict, but we also have the most control over them. You review your spending and determine each item’s value. You might see that you’re spending $1,000 a month on eating out. And then you ask, is spending that amount serving me?
Third, consider big-picture goals: Do you want to tackle debt, or savings, or investing? But the key is to start from a place of honesty, no matter how much you don’t want to see those numbers. Starting from a truthful place allows us to make small, incremental changes. If you create a budget based only on where you want to be, you’re setting yourself up for failure.
This is all about being all honest with yourself.
I call it a “slap-in-the-face” moment. When my community members come to me after they finish this step, they’re like, “Holy crap, I did not realize I was spending $800 a month on clothes.” It’s a slap in the face to learn that you’re spending so much on things that don’t necessarily serve you. It’s very powerful. You can’t change what you don’t know when you’re creating a budget.
Have you ever had to cut down on spending for a trade-off that was worth it?
After I got a divorce, I went on a spending spree. I would tell myself that I just needed time to myself, and I would end up at the mall, putting purchases on my credit card. It took me years to be able to say that I was overspending because I didn’t like how I looked. This was a very hard realization, but I challenged myself to stop spending on my outside appearance for a year — no makeup, no tanning, no new clothes — to focus on my natural self. In the process, I learned to love every aspect of myself. And I started to channel my spending towards things that really did matter, like memories and experiences with my family.
This article is intended as general information only and is not to be relied upon as constituting legal, financial or other professional advice. A professional advisor should be consulted regarding your specific situation. Information presented is believed to be factual and up-to-date but we do not guarantee its accuracy and it should not be regarded as a complete analysis of the subjects discussed. All expressions of opinion reflect the judgment of the authors as of the date of publication and are subject to change. No endorsement of any third parties or their advice, opinions, information, products or services is expressly given or implied by Royal Bank of Canada or any of its affiliates.